Monday, April 21, 2008

A chef and a cook: Therein lies the difference between Jamie and Sunny

As promised a quick review of the other two new Food Network cooking shows:

The Chef
Jamie Oliver, the artist formerly known as "The Naked Chef," has re-invented himself, not so much in how he prepares food, but in how he presents it.

Jamie first impressed viewers in 1998 when, at the age of 22, his "Naked Chef" show featured the spiky-haired urbanite zooming around London on his moped, securing fresh ingredients for simple (but not simplistic) flavorful dinners he'd prepare in his loft apartment kitchen and serve to his posh Gen X friends.

The pace of the show was quick, modern and uber-hip, and Oliver became a minor celebrity.

Today, after seven years in which he pursued a variety of activities -- most notably trying to rid Britain's public schools of processed foods -- Oliver's back as a laid-back Birkenstock-wearing country boy.

The new show is as sparsely produced as is Oliver's food, and that drives home the point. You see extreme close-ups of brightly colored food (and of Oliver's sausage-like fingers). You hear no music, only the chopping, popping, sizzling and splashing of food preparation.

The second episode of "Jamie at Home" featured asparagus, prepared in a variety of ways, redolent of the simple Mediterranean flavors and aromas he'd first presented in "The Naked Chef."

One scene finds Oliver sitting in his herb garden (herb pronounced with the full English "H" of course), pulling some chervil from a plant, adding it to a sizzling pan of olive oil, then frying up some fresh fish and asparagus. Yummy.

The only issue for American viewers is translating all the metric measurements (500 grams of this and 250 grams of that) into American units. (The series is produced by the BBC, and it debuted in Europe last year.)

At the end of the day, though, it's clear Oliver is a talented young chef whose basic theme -- simple, fresh and elegant foods can be prepared by anyone, anywhere -- is a timeless message that's as important today as it was 10 years ago.

The Cook
Oliver's training contrasts greatly with that of "Cooking for Real" host Sunny Anderson's training.

Anderson is an Air Force veteran who has run her own caterinig business and has served as food editor at Hip Hop Weekly magazine. She's not a chef, and she makes no claims to be one.

Unfortunately, the recipes she puts together on her show underscore that.

Her second episode, "Mexin' it Up," featured recipes that both echo and contradict Oliver's call for freshness. She forgets the importance of simplicity, however, in an attempt to create uniqueness.

For example, she creates an interesting (if not all that appetizing) version of huevos rancheros featuring all fresh ingredients. She bakes them in ramekins, but the end result isn't as appealing as she tells us it will be. Contrasting that is a batch of deep-fried churros that ends up being so time consuming and intensive that no home viewer is likely to take that much time and expend that much effort.

Where Oliver is a chef who also understands the challenges his non-chef viewers face daily, Anderson is a cook who works too hard to make up for that difference.

Still, Anderson's show in its infancy is better than anything Rachael Ray has done in her decades (or does it just seem that long) on television.


3 comments:

Anonymous said...

Hello. This post is likeable, and your blog is very interesting, congratulations :-). I will add in my blogroll =). If possible gives a last there on my blog, it is about the Smartphone, I hope you enjoy. The address is http://smartphone-brasil.blogspot.com. A hug.

Matt Brown said...

Totally agree. Oliver is a bona-fide B.A. And the comment about Rachel Ray is spot on.

Matt said...

Hey, JB. Your blog is a boon for foodies.

Thoughts on the FC restaurateur exodus? Bear Rock, Bennigans, Savoy Brasserie ... I'm pretty sure the building is cursed in the latter instance. It is right next to a graveyard, and I once shook hand with Sonny there when it was still Mulligans.

Hopefully my comment is as witty as smartphone down there ...


Noltzo